OGDEN, Utah – The tragic death of 12-year-old Gavin Peterson last summer has led to criminal charges against several of his family members. On Thursday, his father and older brother appeared in court to enter their pleas in connection to his death.
Gavin passed away on July 9, 2024, at a Weber County hospital, and just days later, authorities arrested three of his family members on child abuse homicide charges. A report from the Utah Division of Child and Family Services (DCFS) later revealed that Gavin endured years of severe abuse and neglect.
Court Proceedings
Shane Jesse Peterson, Gavin’s father, was the first to appear before Judge Camille L. Neider in the Second District Court. He faced five felony charges, including child abuse homicide, multiple counts of aggravated child abuse, and endangerment of a minor.
During the hearing, Shane Peterson waived his right to a preliminary trial and pleaded guilty to all charges. Judge Neider ordered a pre-sentence investigation report to be completed before his sentencing, which is scheduled for May 6 at 4 p.m.
“Although prison is inevitable in this case, I want you to have the opportunity to review the PSI before sentencing,” Judge Neider told Peterson.
Following a brief recess, Gavin’s older brother, Tyler Shane Peterson, was brought before the court. He faced four felony charges, including child abuse homicide, aggravated child abuse, and obstruction of justice. Like his father, Tyler also waived his right to a preliminary hearing but entered a plea of guilty with a mental condition.
Tyler’s attorney, Ryan Bushell, explained that a psychologist had diagnosed him with autism spectrum disorder, anxiety, depression, and a personality disorder. Based on this assessment, the defense requested that Tyler be released to receive treatment while living with his mother and siblings. Prosecutors did not oppose the request, and Judge Neider approved his conditional release under a pretrial criminal protective order.
“If law enforcement is ever called, they will have the authority to detain him immediately,” the judge stated.
Tyler must comply with several court-ordered conditions, including obeying the law, respecting the protective order, and refraining from domestic violence. His sentencing date has yet to be scheduled.
Community Reactions
Outside the courthouse, community members gathered to show their support for Gavin and demand justice. Child advocate Sabrina Tracy, who has followed the case closely, spoke about her experience attending the hearing.
“I wanted to be here for Gavin,” she said. “Seeing Shane admit his guilt was important. He should feel ashamed for what he did—it was cruel and deliberate.”
Susan Phillips, a former coworker of Shane Peterson, also attended the hearing. She expressed shock over the revelations about his abusive past and voiced concerns over Tyler Peterson’s release.
“I worked with Tyler, and I believe he knew right from wrong,” Phillips said. “He should receive a sentence that reflects the severity of his actions.”
Meanwhile, Gavin’s stepmother, Nichole Scott, is set to appear in court on March 27, where she will also face charges related to his death .
