OGDEN, Utah — The father and brother of 12-year-old Gavin Peterson, who died on July 9, 2024, have entered guilty pleas in connection with his death. The case, which has drawn significant community attention, involves years of reported abuse and neglect.
Years of Abuse Uncovered
Following Gavin’s death, the Utah Division of Child and Family Services released reports detailing years of severe physical abuse and neglect within the Peterson household. The findings described an alarming pattern of mistreatment that ultimately led to the boy’s tragic death.
Court Proceedings
On Thursday, Shane Jesse Peterson, Gavin’s father, appeared before Second District Court Judge Camille L. Neider. He pleaded guilty to five felony charges, including child abuse homicide, aggravated child abuse, and endangerment of a child. Peterson waived his right to a preliminary hearing, and the judge ordered a pre-sentence investigation (PSI) to gather further details before sentencing.
Judge Neider emphasized that a prison sentence is inevitable, but reviewing the PSI would provide clarity in determining the appropriate punishment. Shane Peterson is scheduled to be sentenced on May 6 at 4 p.m.
Later that day, Tyler Shane Peterson, Gavin’s brother, also appeared in court. He faced four felony charges, including child abuse homicide and obstruction of justice. Like his father, he waived his right to a preliminary hearing but entered a guilty plea with a mental condition.
Tyler’s attorney, Ryan Bushell, presented findings from a psychological evaluation, stating that Tyler had been diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder, generalized anxiety disorder, persistent depressive disorder, and other personality disorders. Bushell requested that Tyler be released for treatment while awaiting sentencing, proposing that he live with his mother and siblings. Prosecutors agreed to the request, and Judge Neider approved a pretrial protective order to ensure law enforcement could intervene if necessary.
Under his release conditions, Tyler must not violate any laws, commit domestic violence, or break the protective order placed on his family. A sentencing date has yet to be determined.
Community Response
Outside the courthouse, community members gathered to advocate for justice for Gavin. Sabrina Tracy, a child advocate who has followed the case closely, expressed relief that Shane Peterson admitted guilt.
“I’m glad I got to see him say he was guilty to all five charges,” Tracy said. “What he did was malicious, and he should be ashamed.”
Another attendee, Susan Phillips, who had previously worked with Shane Peterson, said she and her coworkers were stunned by the revelations of abuse.
“I hope he goes away for a long time,” Phillips said. However, she voiced concerns about Tyler Peterson’s release, stating, “Tyler knew right from wrong. He deserves a sentence that reflects the crime he committed.”
Upcoming Court Dates
While Shane Peterson’s sentencing is set for May 6, his wife, Nichole Scott, is scheduled to appear in court on March 27. The case continues to unfold as the community seeks accountability for Gavin’s death.
- Jazz Suffer 14th Loss in 15 Games After 121-110 Defeat - March 28, 2025
- Historic Victory: Alabama Sets NCAA Tournament Record Against BYU - March 28, 2025
- Judge Dismisses Sexual Assault Lawsuit Against U of U—Impact on Victim Explained - March 28, 2025
